Responding to student writing: motivate, not criticise

Ravichandran Vengadasamy, (2002) Responding to student writing: motivate, not criticise. GEMA: Online Journal of Language Studies, 2 (1). pp. 39-47. ISSN 1675-8021


Official URL:


This paper proposes the idea that a teacher can motivate students in the writing class through the type of feedback he or she provides to students written works. This idea, which is partly based on findings of previous studies and partly on the writers classroom experience, report that students feel better motivated to engage in writing activities when they perceive their teachers to be more interested in what they have to say than in their language accuracy. The paper contends that too many error corrections can be discouraging to the learner writer. It supports the notion that teacher response should focus mainly on content. Two major approaches of responding to content are discussed. The first is directive feedback, which is generally felt to be ineffective in promoting autonomous learning. Instructional and evaluative comments are examples of directive feedback. The second and the desired approach is facilitative feedback. In this approach, teachers give comments in the form of ideas, opinions and suggestions all of which portray the teachers as interested readers. Such an approach is learner-centred and promotes autonomous learning, thereby increasing the level of motivation in the students.

Item Type:Article
Journal:GEMA ; Online Journal of Language Studies
ID Code:718
Deposited By: Mr Fazli Nafiah -
Deposited On:30 Mar 2011 07:38
Last Modified:14 Dec 2016 06:27

Repository Staff Only: item control page